On the Creativity of Limited Beings
As a programmer who has barely written a line of code in the past year, I have asked myself the question that many of us are asking now: if a machine can do my work better than me, what is left of me? I don’t have a complete answer, but I think I have a partial one, and it comes from an unlikely place: our limitations.
A view from everywhere
Years ago I wrote about how there is no “view from nowhere”, that each of us sees the world from one particular spot, and that this is not a flaw to be corrected but simply what it means to be a person. I still believe that. What I did not expect is that we would build something that comes close to the opposite: a view from everywhere.
That is, roughly, what a large language model is. It has read more than any human could read in a thousand lifetimes, and when you ask it something, every concept it has ever encountered tugs at its answer. Not one perspective, but the blurred sum of millions. What comes out is, almost by definition, the most agreeable answer: the one that the most people, on average, would have given.
And this is exactly why it so often feels like nothing.
What limits give us
Now think about what happens when you ask a person the same question. A person has read a handful of books, lived in a couple of cities, loved a few people, failed at a few things. When a question lands on them, it connects to a small, oddly shaped collection of experiences and nowhere else. It does not get pulled in every direction, because there are not that many directions to be pulled in.
We usually call this bias, and it is. We don’t see all the options, so we pick the one in front of us. But look at what else this does: it lets us commit. It lets us go deep into one path instead of hovering above all of them. It gives us a taste, a preference, a direction, and taste is nothing more than a limited perspective that one has made peace with.
This is where creativity lives, I think. Not in having access to every possibility, but in being forced down a narrow one and finding something there that nobody standing in the middle would have found. A creative work is not the average of all works; it is a particular person’s particular world, made visible to the rest of us.
And it is not only art. Even in hard technical problems, being right often requires a nuanced, committed, slightly unreasonable choice; the kind of choice you can only make if you are not simultaneously weighing every alternative with equal seriousness. The machine, pulled in all directions at once, struggles to do precisely this on its own.
I want to be careful here. I am not saying the machine cannot walk a narrow path. It can, and it walks it very well. What it cannot do is choose one. Left alone, with no one to hold it to a direction, it drifts back towards the middle, towards the answer everyone would give, because the middle is where all of its pull comes from. It takes a limited being, someone with a taste and a history and a stubborn sense of what matters, to point at one path and keep it there. The machine can follow that pointing with astonishing skill, but the pointing itself has to come from somewhere narrow.
So what?
If this is right, then the thing we have been treating as our weakness, our narrowness, our one-sidedness, our inability to see the whole picture, is also the thing that makes us capable of producing anything that is more than average. Subjectivity is not what gets in the way of good work. It is what good work is made of. And it suggests a different picture of where we fit next to these machines: not as the ones who know, or even the ones who make, but as the ones who point. The machine supplies the reach; a person supplies the direction. Neither is much use without the other.
I don’t want to be too comfortable with this. It is possible that someone builds a model that is deliberately narrow, trained on one life’s worth of experience, and that it turns out to have a perspective of its own. I don’t know what I would say then. But for now, when I wonder what my value is next to a machine that knows everything, the answer seems to be: I am the one who doesn’t.